riemann

The Lean code claims a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis. This site has not checked the claim yet. See what is checked.

Arakelov geometry and heights

Hermitian line bundles, arithmetic intersection numbers and heights, the arithmetic volume with the theorems of Hilbert-Samuel, Moriwaki and Yuan, Hermitian lattices and their slopes, and the Hodge bundle of an abelian scheme. The volume branch of the Weil bound uses them.

Prerequisites: Algebraic and complex geometry.

Arakelov geometry treats a scheme over ℤ\mathbb{Z} together with a metric on its complex points, the archimedean place. The Weil bound turns an intersection number of Hodge line bundles on unitary Shimura varieties into many small sections, and bounds the errors by slopes.

Hermitian line bundles

Let MM be a complex manifold and LL a holomorphic line bundle on MM.

Definition. A Hermitian metric on LL is a family of Hermitian norms ∥⋅∥\|\cdot\| on the fibres LxL_x that depends smoothly on xx. For compact MM the sup norm of a section is ∥s∥sup⁡=sup⁡x∈M∥s(x)∥\|s\|_{\sup} = \sup_{x \in M} \|s(x)\|.

Put dc=14πi(∂−∂ˉ)d^c = \frac{1}{4\pi i}(\partial - \bar\partial), so that ddc=i2π∂∂ˉdd^c = \frac{i}{2\pi}\partial\bar\partial.

Definition. The Chern form of L‾=(L,∥⋅∥)\overline{L} = (L, \|\cdot\|) is the real (1,1)(1,1)-form c1(L‾)=−ddclog⁡∥e∥2c_1(\overline{L}) = -dd^c \log \|e\|^2 for any local nonvanishing holomorphic section ee. It does not depend on ee, it is closed, and its class in H2(M,ℝ)H^2(M, \mathbb{R}) is the Chern class c1(L)c_1(L).

Example. The Fubini-Study metric on 𝒪(1)\mathcal{O}(1) over ℙn(ℂ)\mathbb{P}^n(\mathbb{C}) gives a linear form ss the norm ∥s∥(x)=∣s(x)∣/(∑i∣xi∣2)1/2\|s\|(x) = |s(x)|/(\sum_i |x_i|^2)^{1/2}. Its Chern form is the Fubini-Study Kähler form, and ∫ℙnc1n=1\int_{\mathbb{P}^n} c_1^n = 1.

Definition. The metric is semipositive if c1(L‾)c_1(\overline{L}) is a semipositive (1,1)(1,1)-form, that is, if each −log⁡∥e∥2-\log\|e\|^2 is plurisubharmonic, and positive if c1(L‾)c_1(\overline{L}) is positive definite at each point.

If MM is projective of dimension DD, then ∫Mc1(L‾)D=(LD)\int_M c_1(\overline{L})^D = (L^D) for each smooth metric (ChernDegree, inside the input ArDegree of the literature chapter).

Theorem (Poincaré-Lelong formula). Let ss be a nonzero meromorphic section of LL. Then, as currents on MM,

ddclog⁡∥s∥2=δdiv⁡s−c1(L‾),dd^c \log\|s\|^2 = \delta_{\operatorname{div} s} - c_1(\overline{L}),

where δdiv⁡s\delta_{\operatorname{div} s} is the current of integration over the divisor of ss, with multiplicities.

With Stokes' theorem, the Poincaré-Lelong formula turns integrals of log⁡∥s∥\log\|s\| against closed forms into integrals over div⁡s\operatorname{div} s. An integrated form, PoincareLelongInv, is an input of the Weil bound.

Arithmetic varieties and intersection numbers

Definition. An arithmetic variety of dimension D+1D + 1 is an integral scheme XX, flat and projective over Spec ℤ\mathrm{Spec}\,\mathbb{Z}, with generic fibre XℚX_{\mathbb{Q}} of dimension DD. Complex conjugation F∞F_\infty acts on X(ℂ)X(\mathbb{C}). A Hermitian line bundle L‾\overline{L} on XX is a line bundle LL with a smooth F∞F_\infty-invariant Hermitian metric on LℂL_{\mathbb{C}} over X(ℂ)X(\mathbb{C}).

Definition (arithmetic degree). Let KK be a number field and L‾\overline{L} a Hermitian line bundle on Spec 𝒪K\mathrm{Spec}\,\mathcal{O}_K, that is, a projective 𝒪K\mathcal{O}_K-module of rank 11 with a norm ∥⋅∥σ\|\cdot\|_\sigma at each embedding σ:K→ℂ\sigma : K \to \mathbb{C}. Its arithmetic degree is

deg⁡^(L‾)=log⁡#(L/𝒪Ks)−∑σlog⁡∥s∥σ\widehat{\deg}(\overline{L}) = \log \#(L/\mathcal{O}_K s) - \sum_{\sigma} \log\|s\|_\sigma

for any nonzero s∈Ls \in L, independent of ss by the product formula.

An arithmetic curve in XX is an integral closed subscheme of dimension 11 that is flat over ℤ\mathbb{Z}. It is the closure CxC_x of a closed point xx of XℚX_{\mathbb{Q}}, and deg⁡^(L‾∣Cx)\widehat{\deg}(\overline{L}|_{C_x}) is the arithmetic degree on the normalization of CxC_x.

For XX regular, Gillet and Soulé defined an arithmetic Chow ring CH^∗(X)\widehat{\mathrm{CH}}^*(X) with first Chern classes c^1(L‾)\widehat{c}_1(\overline{L}) and a degree map deg⁡^:CH^D+1(X)→ℝ\widehat{\deg} : \widehat{\mathrm{CH}}^{D+1}(X) \to \mathbb{R} (Gillet and Soulé, 1990). The arithmetic intersection number of L‾1,…,L‾D+1\overline{L}_1, \dots, \overline{L}_{D+1} is L‾1⋯L‾D+1=deg⁡^(c^1(L‾1)⋯c^1(L‾D+1))\overline{L}_1 \cdots \overline{L}_{D+1} = \widehat{\deg}(\widehat{c}_1(\overline{L}_1) \cdots \widehat{c}_1(\overline{L}_{D+1})), and L‾D+1\overline{L}^{D+1} is the self-intersection.

Proposition (inductive formula). Let ss be a section of LD+1L_{D+1} whose divisor meets the relevant subvarieties properly. Then

L‾1⋯L‾D+1⋅X=L‾1⋯L‾D⋅div⁡(s)−∫X(ℂ)log⁡∥s∥  c1(L‾1)∧⋯∧c1(L‾D),\overline{L}_1 \cdots \overline{L}_{D+1} \cdot X = \overline{L}_1 \cdots \overline{L}_D \cdot \operatorname{div}(s) - \int_{X(\mathbb{C})} \log\|s\|\; c_1(\overline{L}_1) \wedge \cdots \wedge c_1(\overline{L}_D),

where a component of div⁡(s)\operatorname{div}(s) in the fibre over a prime pp contributes its geometric intersection number times log⁡p\log p (Bost, Gillet and Soulé, 1994).

By induction down to arithmetic curves it computes all intersection numbers, and it defines them when XX is not regular (Zhang, 1995).

Theorem (projection formula). Let f:Y→Xf : Y \to X be a generically finite morphism of arithmetic varieties of the same dimension. Then f∗L‾1⋯f∗L‾D+1=deg⁡(f) L‾1⋯L‾D+1f^*\overline{L}_1 \cdots f^*\overline{L}_{D+1} = \deg(f)\, \overline{L}_1 \cdots \overline{L}_{D+1}.

ArDegree contains the birational case, and the Lean code of the Weil bound takes the numbers from an abstract IntersectionSystem with axioms rather than from Gillet and Soulé's construction.

Heights

Definition. Let KK be a number field. The height of P=(x0:⋯:xn)∈ℙn(K)P = (x_0 : \cdots : x_n) \in \mathbb{P}^n(K) is

H(P)=∏vmax⁡i∣xi∣vdv/[K:ℚ],H(P) = \prod_{v} \max_i |x_i|_v^{d_v/[K:\mathbb{Q}]},

over all places vv of KK, where ∣⋅∣v|\cdot|_v extends the usual absolute value of ℚp\mathbb{Q}_p or ℝ\mathbb{R} and dv=[Kv:ℚv]d_v = [K_v : \mathbb{Q}_v]. It does not depend on the coordinates or on KK. The logarithmic height is h(P)=log⁡H(P)h(P) = \log H(P), and a map φ:X→ℙn\varphi : X \to \mathbb{P}^n gives the height function h∘φh \circ \varphi.

Theorem (Northcott). For each BB and dd there are only finitely many P∈ℙn(ℚ‾)P \in \mathbb{P}^n(\overline{\mathbb{Q}}) with h(P)≤Bh(P) \leq B and [ℚ(P):ℚ]≤d[\mathbb{Q}(P) : \mathbb{Q}] \leq d.

Definition. Let L‾\overline{L} be a Hermitian line bundle on an arithmetic variety XX. The height of x∈X(ℚ‾)x \in X(\overline{\mathbb{Q}}) is hL‾(x)=deg⁡^(L‾∣Cx)/[ℚ(x):ℚ]h_{\overline{L}}(x) = \widehat{\deg}(\overline{L}|_{C_x})/[\mathbb{Q}(x) : \mathbb{Q}]. The height of a cycle Z⊂XZ \subset X, integral of dimension r+1r + 1, is hL‾(Z)=L‾r+1⋅Zh_{\overline{L}}(Z) = \overline{L}^{r+1} \cdot Z, and its normalized height is hL‾(Z)/((r+1)deg⁡L(Zℚ))h_{\overline{L}}(Z)/((r+1)\deg_L(Z_{\mathbb{Q}})).

Example. For 𝒪(1)\mathcal{O}(1) on ℙℤn\mathbb{P}^n_{\mathbb{Z}} with the Fubini-Study metric, 0≤hL‾(P)−h(P)≤12log⁡(n+1)0 \leq h_{\overline{L}}(P) - h(P) \leq \frac12 \log(n+1). Heights of cycles enter the published arithmetic results as CycleHeights.

Definition (successive minima). For 1≤i≤D+11 \leq i \leq D + 1 let

ei(L‾)=sup⁡Yinf⁡x∈X(ℚ‾)∖YhL‾(x),e_i(\overline{L}) = \sup_{Y} \inf_{x \in X(\overline{\mathbb{Q}}) \setminus Y} h_{\overline{L}}(x),

where YY runs over the closed subsets of XℚX_{\mathbb{Q}} of codimension ii. So e1e_1 is the essential minimum and eD+1e_{D+1} is the infimum of all heights.

Theorem (Zhang's successive minima). Let L‾\overline{L} be a Hermitian line bundle on XX with LℚL_{\mathbb{Q}} ample, LL nef on each closed fibre and c1(L‾)≥0c_1(\overline{L}) \geq 0. Then

e1(L‾)≥L‾D+1(D+1)deg⁡L(Xℚ)≥1D+1∑i=1D+1ei(L‾)e_1(\overline{L}) \geq \frac{\overline{L}^{D+1}}{(D+1)\deg_L(X_{\mathbb{Q}})} \geq \frac{1}{D+1} \sum_{i=1}^{D+1} e_i(\overline{L})

(Zhang, 1995).

The Weil bound derives two bounds of this shape: a lower bound for A‾D+1\overline{A}^{D+1} from heights of all arithmetic curves, and an upper bound from heights of a Zariski dense set of curves, which yields the Siegel lemma below.

Arithmetic volume and bigness

Let L‾\overline{L} be a Hermitian line bundle on an arithmetic variety XX of dimension D+1D + 1.

Definition. The finite set of small sections is H^0(X,L‾)={s∈H0(X,L):∥s∥sup⁡≤1}\widehat{H}^0(X, \overline{L}) = \{s \in H^0(X, L) : \|s\|_{\sup} \leq 1\}. The arithmetic volume is

vol^(L‾)=lim sup⁡n→∞log⁡#H^0(X,L‾⊗n)nD+1/(D+1)!.\widehat{\mathrm{vol}}(\overline{L}) = \limsup_{n \to \infty} \frac{\log \#\widehat{H}^0(X, \overline{L}^{\otimes n})}{n^{D+1}/(D+1)!}.

L‾\overline{L} is big if vol^(L‾)>0\widehat{\mathrm{vol}}(\overline{L}) > 0, and nef if c1(L‾)≥0c_1(\overline{L}) \geq 0 and deg⁡^(L‾∣C)≥0\widehat{\deg}(\overline{L}|_C) \geq 0 for each integral closed subscheme CC of dimension 11.

Theorem (arithmetic Hilbert-Samuel). Let XX have smooth generic fibre, LL ample and c1(L‾)c_1(\overline{L}) positive. For a lattice MM with a norm on MℝM_{\mathbb{R}} put χ^(M)=log⁡(vol⁡(B)/covol⁡(M))\widehat{\chi}(M) = \log(\operatorname{vol}(B)/\operatorname{covol}(M)), where BB is the unit ball. Then

χ^(H0(X,L⊗n),∥⋅∥sup⁡)=L‾D+1(D+1)! nD+1+o(nD+1)\widehat{\chi}\big(H^0(X, L^{\otimes n}), \|\cdot\|_{\sup}\big) = \frac{\overline{L}^{D+1}}{(D+1)!}\, n^{D+1} + o(n^{D+1})

(Gillet and Soulé, 1992; Abbes and Bouche, 1995; Zhang, 1995). If L‾\overline{L} is also nef, then vol^(L‾)=L‾D+1\widehat{\mathrm{vol}}(\overline{L}) = \overline{L}^{D+1} by the theorem of Moriwaki below. The proof needs only vol^(A‾)≤A‾D+1\widehat{\mathrm{vol}}(\overline{A}) \leq \overline{A}^{D+1} for nef A‾\overline{A} (ArithmeticVolumeNef in HSUse).

Theorem (Moriwaki and Yuan). If L‾\overline{L} and M‾\overline{M} are nef, then vol^(L‾⊗M‾−1)≥L‾D+1−(D+1) L‾D⋅M‾\widehat{\mathrm{vol}}(\overline{L} \otimes \overline{M}^{-1}) \geq \overline{L}^{D+1} - (D+1)\, \overline{L}^D \cdot \overline{M} (Yuan, 2008). The volume is continuous, and vol^(L‾)=L‾D+1\widehat{\mathrm{vol}}(\overline{L}) = \overline{L}^{D+1} for nef L‾\overline{L} (Moriwaki, 2009).

So a nef L‾\overline{L} with L‾D+1>0\overline{L}^{D+1} > 0 is big. The proof states only A‾D+1≤vol^(A‾)\overline{A}^{D+1} \leq \widehat{\mathrm{vol}}(\overline{A}) for semipositive A‾\overline{A} nef on the fibres and on the generic fibre, as MoriwakiBigStatement, and uses it to count small cusp sections.

Theorem (arithmetic Kleiman criterion). In the form ArithKleiman of HSUse: a nef Hermitian line bundle A‾\overline{A} with nonnegative heights on all arithmetic curves has A‾D+1≥0\overline{A}^{D+1} \geq 0.

Hermitian lattices and slopes

Definition. A Euclidean lattice is a free ℤ\mathbb{Z}-module EE of finite rank with a Euclidean norm on EℝE_{\mathbb{R}}. Its degree is deg⁡^(E‾)=−log⁡covol⁡(E)\widehat{\deg}(\overline{E}) = -\log \operatorname{covol}(E).

Definition. Let KK be a number field. A Hermitian lattice over 𝒪K\mathcal{O}_K is a finitely generated projective 𝒪K\mathcal{O}_K-module EE with a Hermitian norm ∥⋅∥σ\|\cdot\|_\sigma on E⊗σℂE \otimes_\sigma \mathbb{C} for each σ:K→ℂ\sigma : K \to \mathbb{C}, with ∥⋅∥σˉ\|\cdot\|_{\bar\sigma} the conjugate of ∥⋅∥σ\|\cdot\|_\sigma. Its degree deg⁡^(E‾)\widehat{\deg}(\overline{E}) is the arithmetic degree of det⁡E\det E with the induced metric. The normalized degree is deg⁡^n(E‾)=deg⁡^(E‾)/[K:ℚ]\widehat{\deg}_n(\overline{E}) = \widehat{\deg}(\overline{E})/[K : \mathbb{Q}], and the slope is μ(E‾)=deg⁡^n(E‾)/rank⁡E\mu(\overline{E}) = \widehat{\deg}_n(\overline{E})/\operatorname{rank} E. Both are unchanged by extension of scalars to a larger number field.

Definition. The maximal slope μmax⁡(E‾)\mu_{\max}(\overline{E}) is the supremum, which is attained, of μ(F‾)\mu(\overline{F}) over the nonzero submodules F⊂EF \subset E with the restricted norms.

Example. By Minkowski's theorem in the geometry of numbers, a Euclidean lattice of rank nn has a vector v≠0v \neq 0 with log⁡∥v∥≤12log⁡n−μ(E‾)\log\|v\| \leq \frac12 \log n - \mu(\overline{E}), that is, a line ℤv\mathbb{Z}v of degree at least μ(E‾)−12log⁡n\mu(\overline{E}) - \frac12 \log n.

Theorem (absolute Siegel lemma). For each number field KK, each Hermitian lattice F‾\overline{F} of rank i≥1i \geq 1 over 𝒪K\mathcal{O}_K and each ε>0\varepsilon > 0, there are a finite extension K′K' and a vector v≠0v \neq 0 of F⊗𝒪K′F \otimes \mathcal{O}_{K'} with

μ(F‾)−12log⁡i−ε≤deg⁡^K′(v),\mu(\overline{F}) - \tfrac12 \log i - \varepsilon \leq \widehat{\deg}_{K'}(v),

where deg⁡^K′(v)\widehat{\deg}_{K'}(v) is the normalized degree of the line that vv spans (Zhang, 1995; Roy and Thunder, 1996).

This is LineOfLargeDegree in the Weil bound, which the code derives from Zhang's upper bound above.

Theorem (Bost slope inequality). Let E‾,F‾\overline{E}, \overline{F} be Hermitian lattices over 𝒪K\mathcal{O}_K and φ:E→F\varphi : E \to F an injective 𝒪K\mathcal{O}_K-linear map with ∥φ(x)∥σ≤C∥x∥σ\|\varphi(x)\|_\sigma \leq C\|x\|_\sigma at each σ\sigma. Then μ(E‾)≤μmax⁡(F‾)+log⁡C\mu(\overline{E}) \leq \mu_{\max}(\overline{F}) + \log C (Bost, 1996).

The code proves it, but the Weil bound bounds slopes by short vectors from the Siegel lemma instead.

The Hodge bundle and Zarhin's trick

Let A→SA \to S be an abelian or semi-abelian scheme of relative dimension gg with zero section ee, as in the elliptic curves chapter.

Definition. The Hodge bundle is ωA/S=e∗ΩA/S1\omega_{A/S} = e^*\Omega^1_{A/S}, a vector bundle of rank gg on SS, dual to Lie⁡(A)\operatorname{Lie}(A). The Hodge line bundle is det⁡ωA/S\det \omega_{A/S}. At a complex point ss, the Hodge metric on det⁡ω\det\omega is ∥α∥2=ig22g∫As(ℂ)α∧αˉ\|\alpha\|^2 = \frac{i^{g^2}}{2^g} \int_{A_s(\mathbb{C})} \alpha \wedge \bar\alpha. The proof also puts a Hodge metric on Lie⁡(A)\operatorname{Lie}(A).

For an abelian variety over a number field with semistable reduction, the Faltings height is the normalized arithmetic degree of the Hodge line bundle of the Néron model with this metric.

Theorem (semipositivity of the Hodge bundle). The Hodge metric on det⁡ω\det\omega over a complex base has semipositive Chern form (Griffiths). Let CC be a smooth projective geometrically connected curve over a field of characteristic 00 and GG a semi-abelian scheme over CC. Then every vector bundle WW that injects into Lie⁡(G)\operatorname{Lie}(G) has deg⁡det⁡W≤0\deg \det W \leq 0 (Moret-Bailly, 1985; Faltings and Chai, 1990).

The second statement, SemiAbelianLieSeminegative, is the dual form of the nefness of the Hodge bundle. Its arithmetic analogue in the Weil bound, SlopeBoundSt, bounds the maximal slope of the Lie algebra of a semi-abelian scheme, with the Hodge metric, by Clog⁡(2+rank⁡+max⁡(−deg⁡^n,0))C \log(2 + \operatorname{rank} + \max(-\widehat{\deg}_n, 0)).

Theorem (Zarhin's trick). For each abelian variety AA over a field, (A×A∨)4(A \times A^\vee)^4 has a principal polarization (Zarhin, 1974).

The Weil bound uses it as ZarhinStatement: over the valuation ring of an algebraically closed valued field, a polarizable abelian scheme is a retract of a principally polarized one.

Further reading

  • C. Soulé, D. Abramovich, J.-F. Burnol and J. Kramer, Lectures on Arakelov Geometry, Chapters II to IV.
  • J.-B. Bost, H. Gillet and C. Soulé, Heights of projective varieties and positive Green forms, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 7 (1994), Sections 2 and 3.
  • E. Bombieri and W. Gubler, Heights in Diophantine Geometry, Chapters 1 and 2.
  • J.-B. Bost, Périodes et isogénies des variétés abéliennes sur les corps de nombres, Séminaire Bourbaki 795, Astérisque 237 (1996), Sections 4 and 5.
  • G. Faltings and C.-L. Chai, Degeneration of Abelian Varieties, Chapters IV and V.

The source of this page. Markdown. Something is wrong? Report it.