riemann

The Lean code claims a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis. This site has not checked the claim yet. See what is checked.

Formal groups and p-divisible groups

Formal group laws, p-divisible groups and their Dieudonné modules, up to prismatic Dieudonné theory over AinfA_{\mathrm{inf}} and Grothendieck-Messing deformation theory. The proof uses them in its prismatic Dieudonné statement and as named literature inputs.

Prerequisites: Galois representations.

A formal group law is a group law given by power series. A pp-divisible group is a tower of finite group schemes G[pn]G[p^n] whose connected part is a formal group, and over the ring of integers of ℂp\mathbb{C}_p such groups are described by linear algebra over Fontaine's ring AinfA_{\mathrm{inf}}. The proof uses formal groups to prove a prismatic Dieudonné statement, and Grothendieck-Messing deformation theory and the Hodge-Tate sequence as named inputs.

Formal group laws

Let RR be a commutative ring, and write X=(X1,…,Xn)X = (X_1, \dots, X_n) and Y=(Y1,…,Yn)Y = (Y_1, \dots, Y_n).

Definition. A commutative formal group law of dimension nn over RR is an nn-tuple F(X,Y)F(X, Y) of power series in R[[X,Y]]R[[X, Y]] with F(X,0)=XF(X, 0) = X, F(0,Y)=YF(0, Y) = Y, F(F(X,Y),Z)=F(X,F(Y,Z))F(F(X, Y), Z) = F(X, F(Y, Z)) and F(X,Y)=F(Y,X)F(X, Y) = F(Y, X). A homomorphism f:F→Gf : F \to G to a formal group law GG of dimension mm is an mm-tuple of series f(X)f(X) without constant term with f(F(X,Y))=G(f(X),f(Y))f(F(X, Y)) = G(f(X), f(Y)).

Then F(X,Y)=X+Y+(terms of degree≥2)F(X, Y) = X + Y + (\text{terms of degree} \geq 2), there is a unique series ι(X)\iota(X) with F(X,ι(X))=0F(X, \iota(X)) = 0, and [m]F[m]_F denotes multiplication by m∈ℤm \in \mathbb{Z}.

Example. The additive formal group 𝔾^a\hat{\mathbb{G}}_a has F(X,Y)=X+YF(X, Y) = X + Y. The multiplicative formal group 𝔾^m\hat{\mathbb{G}}_m has F(X,Y)=X+Y+XY=(1+X)(1+Y)−1F(X, Y) = X + Y + XY = (1 + X)(1 + Y) - 1. Expanding the group law of an elliptic curve in a local parameter zz at OO gives a one-dimensional formal group law (elliptic curves).

Theorem (Lubin-Tate formal group laws; Lubin and Tate, 1965). Let KK be a nonarchimedean local field with uniformizer π\pi and residue field of size qq. Let f∈𝒪K[[X]]f \in \mathcal{O}_K[[X]] satisfy f(X)≡πXf(X) \equiv \pi X modulo degree 22 and f(X)≡Xq(modπ)f(X) \equiv X^q \pmod{\pi}. Then there is a unique formal group law FfF_f over 𝒪K\mathcal{O}_K with f∈End(Ff)f \in \mathrm{End}(F_f), and for each a∈𝒪Ka \in \mathcal{O}_K there is a unique endomorphism [a]f[a]_f of FfF_f with [a]f(X)≡aX[a]_f(X) \equiv aX modulo degree 22.

The πn\pi^n-torsion points of FfF_f generate totally ramified abelian extensions of KK, whose union corresponds to ⟨π⟩\langle \pi \rangle in local class field theory (class field theory).

In CM divisibility, the series μ\mu of Step 2 lifts a formal group law that is a chart of a pp-divisible group.

The invariant derivation and the logarithm

Definition. Let FF be a formal group law of dimension nn over RR, and let u∈Rnu \in R^n. The invariant derivation in the direction uu is the derivation DuD_u of R[[X]]R[[X]] with Dug(X)=∑i=1nui∂∂Yig(F(X,Y))∣Y=0.D_u g(X) = \sum_{i=1}^n u_i \frac{\partial}{\partial Y_i} g(F(X, Y)) \Big|_{Y = 0}.

It commutes with translations: applied in XX to g(F(X,Z))g(F(X, Z)) it gives (Dug)(F(X,Z))(D_u g)(F(X, Z)). The map u↦Duu \mapsto D_u identifies RnR^n with the Lie algebra Lie(F)\mathrm{Lie}(F) of translation-invariant derivations.

Example. For 𝔾^a\hat{\mathbb{G}}_a, D=d/dXD = d/dX. For 𝔾^m\hat{\mathbb{G}}_m, D=(1+X) d/dXD = (1 + X)\, d/dX, and D(1+X)k=k(1+X)kD (1 + X)^k = k (1 + X)^k.

If p=0p = 0 in RR, the pp-th power of a derivation is a derivation, so Dup=Dh(u)D_u^p = D_{h(u)} for a pp-linear map hh, with h(au)=aph(u)h(au) = a^p h(u). Over 𝔽p\mathbb{F}_p the example gives Dp=0D^p = 0 for 𝔾^a\hat{\mathbb{G}}_a and Dp=DD^p = D for 𝔾^m\hat{\mathbb{G}}_m, since kp≡k(modp)k^p \equiv k \pmod p.

Proposition (the logarithm). If RR is a ℚ\mathbb{Q}-algebra, there is a unique nn-tuple log⁡F(X)∈R[[X]]\log_F(X) \in R[[X]] with log⁡F(X)≡X\log_F(X) \equiv X modulo degree 22 and log⁡F(F(X,Y))=log⁡F(X)+log⁡F(Y)\log_F(F(X, Y)) = \log_F(X) + \log_F(Y). It is an isomorphism from FF to 𝔾^an\hat{\mathbb{G}}_a^n.

Example. log⁡𝔾^m(X)=log⁡(1+X)=∑k≥1(−1)k+1Xk/k\log_{\hat{\mathbb{G}}_m}(X) = \log(1 + X) = \sum_{k \geq 1} (-1)^{k+1} X^k / k. Its coefficients have denominators, so 𝔾^m\hat{\mathbb{G}}_m and 𝔾^a\hat{\mathbb{G}}_a are not isomorphic over ℤp\mathbb{Z}_p.

If RR is a ℤ(p)\mathbb{Z}_{(p)}-algebra without pp-torsion, log⁡F\log_F is defined over the ℚ\mathbb{Q}-algebra R[1/p]R[1/p], and its coefficients at the monomials XipX_i^p control DupD_u^p modulo pp. In a frame IsFrame p Q θ, with μ\mu a lift of a formal group law and ll a series that the code calls a quasi-logarithm, the theorem constantCoeff_pIterate_invariantDerivation_coord of CM divisibility says that the constant term of Dup(Xj)D_u^p(X_j) is congruent to ∑iciuip\sum_i c_i u_i^p modulo ker⁡θ+pB\ker\theta + pB, where ci=p⋅[Xip] lc_i = p \cdot [X_i^p]\, l.

Height

Let kk be a field of characteristic pp.

Definition. Let f:F→Gf : F \to G be a nonzero homomorphism of one-dimensional formal group laws over kk. Then f(X)=g(Xph)f(X) = g(X^{p^h}) for a unique h≥0h \geq 0, the height of ff, and a series gg with g′(0)≠0g'(0) \neq 0. The height of FF is the height of [p]F[p]_F, or ∞\infty if [p]F=0[p]_F = 0. For dimension nn, FF has finite height hh if [p]F∗[p]_F^* makes k[[X]]k[[X]] a free module of rank php^h over itself.

Example. Over 𝔽p\mathbb{F}_p, [p]𝔾^m(X)=(1+X)p−1=Xp[p]_{\hat{\mathbb{G}}_m}(X) = (1 + X)^p - 1 = X^p, so 𝔾^m\hat{\mathbb{G}}_m has height 11, and [p]𝔾^a=0[p]_{\hat{\mathbb{G}}_a} = 0, so 𝔾^a\hat{\mathbb{G}}_a has height ∞\infty. The reduction of a Lubin-Tate formal group of KK has height [K:ℚp][K : \mathbb{Q}_p]. The formal group of an elliptic curve over 𝔽‾p\overline{\mathbb{F}}_p has height 11 (ordinary) or 22 (supersingular).

Theorem (Lazard, 1955). Over a separably closed field of characteristic pp, two one-dimensional formal group laws are isomorphic if and only if they have the same height.

In the statement PrismaticDieudonneHodge of CM divisibility, the height of a pp-divisible group (defined below) is the rank of its prismatic Dieudonné module.

p-divisible groups

Definition (Tate, 1967). Let RR be a ring and let h≥0h \geq 0. A pp-divisible group of height hh over RR is a system G=(Gn)n≥1G = (G_n)_{n \geq 1} of finite flat commutative group schemes over RR, with GnG_n of order pnhp^{nh}, and injections Gn→Gn+1G_n \to G_{n+1} that identify GnG_n with the kernel of pnp^n on Gn+1G_{n+1}.

Example. μp∞=(μpn)n\mu_{p^\infty} = (\mu_{p^n})_n and ℚp/ℤp=(ℤ/pn)n\mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p = (\mathbb{Z}/p^n)_n have height 11. For an abelian scheme AA of dimension gg, A[p∞]=(A[pn])nA[p^\infty] = (A[p^n])_n has height 2g2g.

Let RR be a complete noetherian local ring with residue field of characteristic pp. A pp-divisible group is connected (or étale) if each GnG_n is. There is an exact sequence 0→G0→G→Get→00 \to G^0 \to G \to G^{\mathrm{et}} \to 0 with G0G^0 connected and GetG^{\mathrm{et}} étale.

Theorem (Tate, 1967). Over such an RR, the map F↦(ker⁡[pn]F)nF \mapsto (\ker [p^n]_F)_n is an equivalence from formal group laws of finite height to connected pp-divisible groups. It preserves height. The dimension of a pp-divisible group GG is the dimension of the formal group of G0G^0.

Definition. The dual of GG is G∨=(Gn∨)nG^\vee = (G_n^\vee)_n, where Gn∨=Hom(Gn,𝔾m)G_n^\vee = \mathrm{Hom}(G_n, \mathbb{G}_m) is the Cartier dual. It has the same height hh, and dim⁡G+dim⁡G∨=h\dim G + \dim G^\vee = h.

Example. (μp∞)∨=ℚp/ℤp(\mu_{p^\infty})^\vee = \mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p. For an abelian scheme, A[p∞]∨=A∨[p∞]A[p^\infty]^\vee = A^\vee[p^\infty], with A∨A^\vee the dual abelian scheme.

Definition. Let CC be a complete algebraically closed extension of ℚp\mathbb{Q}_p with ring of integers 𝒪C\mathcal{O}_C, and let GG be a pp-divisible group over 𝒪C\mathcal{O}_C. Its Tate module is TpG=lim←⁡nGn(𝒪C)T_p G = \varprojlim_n G_n(\mathcal{O}_C), a free ℤp\mathbb{Z}_p-module of rank hh.

Proposition (the Weil pairing). Cartier duality gives a perfect pairing TpG×TpG∨→Tpμp∞=ℤp(1)T_p G \times T_p G^\vee \to T_p \mu_{p^\infty} = \mathbb{Z}_p(1). For G=A[p∞]G = A[p^\infty] it is the Weil pairing of AA and A∨A^\vee.

The theorem isNil_dual_frobenius of CM divisibility says that the dual Frobenius is nilpotent for a pp-divisible group over 𝒪C\mathcal{O}_C with connected dual.

Dieudonné modules and the Hodge-Tate sequence

Let kk be a perfect field of characteristic pp, let W(k)W(k) be its ring of Witt vectors, and let σ\sigma be the Frobenius of W(k)W(k).

Definition. A Dieudonné module over kk is a free W(k)W(k)-module MM of finite rank with a σ\sigma-linear map FF and a σ−1\sigma^{-1}-linear map VV such that FV=VF=pFV = VF = p.

Theorem (Dieudonné; Fontaine, 1977). There is an anti-equivalence G↦𝔻(G)G \mapsto \mathbb{D}(G) from pp-divisible groups over kk to Dieudonné modules over kk, and the rank of 𝔻(G)\mathbb{D}(G) is the height of GG. The Hodge filtration V𝔻(G)/p𝔻(G)⊂𝔻(G)/p𝔻(G)V\mathbb{D}(G)/p\mathbb{D}(G) \subset \mathbb{D}(G)/p\mathbb{D}(G) is ωG\omega_G, the space of invariant differentials of GG, and the quotient is Lie(G∨)\mathrm{Lie}(G^\vee).

So 0→ωG→𝔻(G)/p→Lie(G∨)→00 \to \omega_G \to \mathbb{D}(G)/p \to \mathrm{Lie}(G^\vee) \to 0 is exact, with dimensions d=dim⁡Gd = \dim G, hh and h−dh - d. In this normalization GG is étale exactly when FF is bijective, and 𝔻(ℚp/ℤp)=W(k)\mathbb{D}(\mathbb{Q}_p/\mathbb{Z}_p) = W(k) with F=1F = 1 and V=pV = p. For an abelian variety AA over kk, 𝔻(A[p∞])\mathbb{D}(A[p^\infty]) is the crystalline cohomology Hcris1(A/W(k))H^1_{\mathrm{cris}}(A/W(k)).

Theorem (Dieudonné-Manin classification). If kk is algebraically closed, then 𝔻(G)[1/p]\mathbb{D}(G)[1/p] is a direct sum of simple isocrystals of slopes λ∈[0,1]∩ℚ\lambda \in [0, 1] \cap \mathbb{Q}, and these slopes, with multiplicities, classify GG up to isogeny.

A supersingular elliptic curve has the slope 1/21/2 twice, and an ordinary one has the slopes 00 and 11.

Definition. Let GG be a pp-divisible group over 𝒪C\mathcal{O}_C. For x∈TpGx \in T_p G, Cartier duality makes xx a map G∨→μp∞G^\vee \to \mu_{p^\infty}, and the pullback of dt/tdt/t is an element αG(x)∈ωG∨\alpha_G(x) \in \omega_{G^\vee}. This gives the Hodge-Tate map αG:TpG⊗𝒪C→ωG∨\alpha_G : T_p G \otimes \mathcal{O}_C \to \omega_{G^\vee}.

Theorem (the Hodge-Tate sequence; Fargues, 2008). The sequence 0→Lie(G)⊗𝒪CC(1)→TpG⊗ℤpC→αGωG∨⊗𝒪CC→00 \to \mathrm{Lie}(G) \otimes_{\mathcal{O}_C} C(1) \to T_p G \otimes_{\mathbb{Z}_p} C \xrightarrow{\alpha_G} \omega_{G^\vee} \otimes_{\mathcal{O}_C} C \to 0 is exact. The first map is the dual of αG∨\alpha_{G^\vee} under the Weil pairing.

The input FarguesExact of the Weil bound is this exactness, in Lean an orthogonality statement under the Weil pairing.

Prismatic Dieudonné theory

Let Ainf=W(𝒪C♭)A_{\mathrm{inf}} = W(\mathcal{O}_{C^\flat}), with θ:Ainf→𝒪C\theta : A_{\mathrm{inf}} \to \mathcal{O}_C, the generator ξ\xi of ker⁡θ\ker\theta and the Frobenius φ\varphi (Galois representations).

Theorem (Scholze and Weinstein, 2013). The functor G↦(TpG,Lie(G)⊗C(1))G \mapsto (T_p G, \mathrm{Lie}(G) \otimes C(1)) is an equivalence from pp-divisible groups over 𝒪C\mathcal{O}_C to pairs (T,W)(T, W), where TT is a free ℤp\mathbb{Z}_p-module of finite rank and W⊂T⊗ℤpCW \subset T \otimes_{\mathbb{Z}_p} C is a CC-subspace.

Theorem (Fargues; see Bhatt, Morrow and Scholze, 2018, section 14). pp-divisible groups over 𝒪C\mathcal{O}_C are equivalent to finite free AinfA_{\mathrm{inf}}-modules MM with a φ\varphi-linear Frobenius that satisfies a minuscule condition with respect to ξ\xi. The rank of MM is the height of GG.

Prismatic Dieudonné theory (Anschütz and Le Bras, 2023) extends this to quasi-syntomic rings RR: pp-divisible groups over RR are equivalent to admissible prismatic Dieudonné crystals. Over 𝒪C\mathcal{O}_C the value on the prism AinfA_{\mathrm{inf}} is the module of Fargues, whose reduction gives the Hodge filtration 0→ωG→D→Lie(G∨)→00 \to \omega_G \to D \to \mathrm{Lie}(G^\vee) \to 0.

Theorem (Bhatt and Scholze, 2023). Let KK be a finite extension of ℚp\mathbb{Q}_p. The étale realization is an equivalence from prismatic F-crystals on 𝒪K\mathcal{O}_K to crystalline lattices: GKG_K-stable ℤp\mathbb{Z}_p-lattices in crystalline representations of GKG_K (Galois representations).

The statement PrismaticDieudonneHodge of CM divisibility, proved as UpperTheory.Lit.prismaticDieudonneHodge, asks for a functor from pp-divisible groups over 𝒪\mathcal{O} to free AinfA_{\mathrm{inf}}-modules of rank the height, with a Frobenius and this Hodge filtration. The record UnitaryGroupThirdPlaceHypotheses has the field bhattScholzeCrystallineLattices.

Grothendieck-Messing deformation theory

Definition. A divided power thickening is a surjection of rings R→R0R \to R_0 whose kernel II has divided powers γn:I→I\gamma_n : I \to I, maps that behave like x↦xn/n!x \mapsto x^n / n!. They are nilpotent if all products of the γn\gamma_n of large enough total degree vanish.

Example. For pp odd, the ideal pW(k)/p2pW(k)/p^2 of W2(k)=W(k)/p2W_2(k) = W(k)/p^2 has nilpotent divided powers with γn(px)=pnxn/n!\gamma_n(px) = p^n x^n / n!.

Theorem (Grothendieck-Messing; Messing, 1972). Let R→R0R \to R_0 be a nilpotent divided power thickening with pp nilpotent in RR, and let G0G_0 be a pp-divisible group over R0R_0. The Dieudonné crystal of G0G_0 gives a locally free RR-module 𝔻(G0)R\mathbb{D}(G_0)_R lifting 𝔻(G0)R0\mathbb{D}(G_0)_{R_0}, and the lifts of G0G_0 to RR, up to isomorphism, correspond to the direct summands of 𝔻(G0)R\mathbb{D}(G_0)_R that lift the Hodge filtration ωG0⊂𝔻(G0)R0\omega_{G_0} \subset \mathbb{D}(G_0)_{R_0}.

So deformation theory of pp-divisible groups is linear algebra. By the Serre-Tate deformation theorem (Katz, 1981), which is not the reduction criterion of elliptic curves, the same holds for abelian schemes.

The field q1 of published-results-arithmetic, of type GrothendieckMessing with pp nilpotent, comes from the input GrothendieckDeformation of cm-abelian-inputs-from-literature.

Further reading

  • J. Tate, p-divisible groups, in Proceedings of a Conference on Local Fields (1967), sections 1 and 2.
  • J. H. Silverman, The Arithmetic of Elliptic Curves, 2nd ed. (2009), chapter IV.
  • M. Demazure, Lectures on p-divisible Groups, LNM 302 (1972), chapters II and III.
  • W. Messing, The Crystals Associated to Barsotti-Tate Groups, LNM 264 (1972), chapter V.
  • P. Scholze and J. Weinstein, Moduli of p-divisible groups, Cambridge J. Math. 1 (2013), sections 4 and 5.

The source of this page. Markdown. Something is wrong? Report it.