riemann

The Lean code claims a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis. This site has not checked the claim yet. See what is checked.

Galois cohomology

Continuous cohomology of Galois groups, the duality theorems over local and global fields, Selmer groups and Iwasawa theory. The window bound of the proof is a bound on lengths of Tate-Shafarevich groups, and its counting argument uses these tools.

Prerequisites: Galois representations.

Galois cohomology is the continuous cohomology of a profinite Galois group. Over local and global fields its groups are finite and satisfy duality theorems, and Selmer and Tate-Shafarevich groups are the subgroups of H1H^1 cut out by local conditions. The window bound bounds the lengths of Tate-Shafarevich groups with these dualities, Iwasawa theory and Kato's Euler system.

Continuous cohomology

Let GG be a profinite group (Galois representations).

Definition. A discrete GG-module is an abelian group MM with an action of GG such that the stabilizer of each m∈Mm \in M is open. Let Cn(G,M)C^n(G, M) be the group of continuous maps Gn→MG^n \to M, with the standard differential of group cohomology (group cohomology). The cohomology of this complex is Hn(G,M)H^n(G, M).

So H0(G,M)=MGH^0(G, M) = M^G, and H1(G,M)H^1(G, M) is the group of continuous ff with f(gh)=f(g)+gf(h)f(gh) = f(g) + g f(h) modulo the maps g↦gm−mg \mapsto gm - m; for trivial action it is Homcont(G,M)\mathrm{Hom}_{\mathrm{cont}}(G, M).

Proposition. Hn(G,M)=lim→⁡UHn(G/U,MU)H^n(G, M) = \varinjlim_U H^n(G/U, M^U) over the open normal subgroups UU, so Hn(G,M)H^n(G, M) is torsion for n≥1n \geq 1. A short exact sequence of discrete modules gives a long exact sequence. For a closed normal subgroup HH, the inflation-restriction sequence 0→H1(G/H,MH)→H1(G,M)→H1(H,M)G/H0 \to H^1(G/H, M^H) \to H^1(G, M) \to H^1(H, M)^{G/H} is exact.

Definition. For a field KK and a discrete GKG_K-module MM, the Galois cohomology of MM is Hn(K,M)=Hn(GK,M)H^n(K, M) = H^n(G_K, M). For a number field KK and a set SS of places, write Hn(GS,M)H^n(G_S, M) when MM is a GSG_S-module.

Example (Kummer theory). If nn is prime to the characteristic of KK, Hilbert's Theorem 90 and the sequence 1→μn→K‾×→K‾×→11 \to \mu_n \to \overline{K}^\times \to \overline{K}^\times \to 1 give H1(K,μn)≅K×/K×nH^1(K, \mu_n) \cong K^\times / K^{\times n}.

Example. For a finite field kk and a finite GkG_k-module MM, H1(k,M)=M/(Frob−1)MH^1(k, M) = M / (\mathrm{Frob} - 1) M and Hn(k,M)=0H^n(k, M) = 0 for n≥2n \geq 2.

HnH^n commutes with direct limits such as ℚℓ/ℤℓ(k)=lim→⁡nℤ/ℓn(k)\mathbb{Q}_\ell/\mathbb{Z}_\ell(k) = \varinjlim_n \mathbb{Z}/\ell^n(k). For compact ℤℓ(k)\mathbb{Z}_\ell(k) put Hn(G,ℤℓ(k))=lim←⁡nHn(G,ℤ/ℓn(k))H^n(G, \mathbb{Z}_\ell(k)) = \varprojlim_n H^n(G, \mathbb{Z}/\ell^n(k)); this agrees with continuous cochain cohomology when each Hn−1(G,ℤ/ℓm(k))H^{n-1}(G, \mathbb{Z}/\ell^m(k)) is finite (Tate, 1976). VWin adds up the lengths of subgroups of H1(GS,ℚl/ℤl(−e))H^1(G_S, \mathbb{Q}_l/\mathbb{Z}_l(-e)) such as the group of VWin.

Local fields

Let KK be a finite extension of ℚp\mathbb{Q}_p, and let MM be a finite GKG_K-module of order mm. Put M∨=Hom(M,μm)M^\vee = \mathrm{Hom}(M, \mu_m); for example (ℤ/ℓn(k))∨=ℤ/ℓn(1−k)(\mathbb{Z}/\ell^n(k))^\vee = \mathbb{Z}/\ell^n(1-k).

Theorem (local finiteness; Tate, 1962). Hn(K,M)H^n(K, M) is finite for each nn and 00 for n≥3n \geq 3, and H2(K,μm)≅ℤ/mℤH^2(K, \mu_m) \cong \mathbb{Z}/m\mathbb{Z}.

Theorem (Local Tate duality; Tate, 1962). For n=0,1,2n = 0, 1, 2, the cup product and H2(K,μm)≅ℤ/mℤH^2(K, \mu_m) \cong \mathbb{Z}/m\mathbb{Z} give a perfect pairing Hn(K,M)×H2−n(K,M∨)→ℚ/ℤH^n(K, M) \times H^{2-n}(K, M^\vee) \to \mathbb{Q}/\mathbb{Z}.

Theorem (local Euler characteristic formula; Tate, 1962). #H0(K,M) #H2(K,M)#H1(K,M)=p−vp(m)[K:ℚp].\frac{\#H^0(K, M)\, \#H^2(K, M)}{\#H^1(K, M)} = p^{-v_p(m)[K : \mathbb{Q}_p]}.

Example. For M=μpM = \mu_p and K=ℚpK = \mathbb{Q}_p with pp odd, H0=0H^0 = 0 and H2=ℤ/pH^2 = \mathbb{Z}/p, so #H1(ℚp,μp)=p2\#H^1(\mathbb{Q}_p, \mu_p) = p^2, in agreement with ℚp×/ℚp×p≅(ℤ/p)2\mathbb{Q}_p^\times / \mathbb{Q}_p^{\times p} \cong (\mathbb{Z}/p)^2.

Definition. The unramified classes are Hur1(K,M)=ker⁡(H1(K,M)→H1(IK,M))=H1(GK/IK,MIK)H^1_{\mathrm{ur}}(K, M) = \ker(H^1(K, M) \to H^1(I_K, M)) = H^1(G_K / I_K, M^{I_K}).

Proposition. If MM is unramified and p∤mp \nmid m, then Hur1(K,M)H^1_{\mathrm{ur}}(K, M) and Hur1(K,M∨)H^1_{\mathrm{ur}}(K, M^\vee) are exact annihilators under local Tate duality.

The bundle coh : LitCoh of the window bound states the three theorems, and vwin_of_counts takes LocalFinitenessK and LocalTateDualityK as hypotheses.

Global fields

Let KK be a number field, let MM be a finite GKG_K-module of order mm, and let SS be a finite set of places that contains the infinite places, the places above the primes dividing mm, and the places where MM is ramified. Then MM and M∨M^\vee are GSG_S-modules.

Theorem (Tate). The groups Hn(GS,M)H^n(G_S, M) are finite.

Theorem (Tate global Euler characteristic formula; Tate, 1962). #H0(GS,M) #H2(GS,M)#H1(GS,M)=∏v∣∞#H0(Kv,M)∣m∣v,\frac{\#H^0(G_S, M)\, \#H^2(G_S, M)}{\#H^1(G_S, M)} = \prod_{v \mid \infty} \frac{\#H^0(K_v, M)}{|m|_v}, where ∣m∣v=m|m|_v = m for a real place and ∣m∣v=m2|m|_v = m^2 for a complex place.

Example. If KK is totally complex of degree nn, the ratio is (m/m2)n/2=m−n/2(m/m^2)^{n/2} = m^{-n/2}.

Definition. For n=1,2n = 1, 2, put ШSn(M)=ker⁡(Hn(GS,M)→∏v∈SHn(Kv,M))\text{Ш}^n_S(M) = \ker\big(H^n(G_S, M) \to \prod_{v \in S} H^n(K_v, M)\big).

Theorem (Poitou-Tate duality; Poitou and Tate, 1962 and 1963). The local Tate pairings give a perfect pairing ШS1(M)×ШS2(M∨)→ℚ/ℤ\text{Ш}^1_S(M) \times \text{Ш}^2_S(M^\vee) \to \mathbb{Q}/\mathbb{Z} and an exact sequence 0→H0→PS0→(H∨2)∗→H1→PS1→(H∨1)∗→H2→PS2→(H∨0)∗→0,0 \to H^0 \to P^0_S \to (H^2_\vee)^* \to H^1 \to P^1_S \to (H^1_\vee)^* \to H^2 \to P^2_S \to (H^0_\vee)^* \to 0, where Hn=Hn(GS,M)H^n = H^n(G_S, M), H∨n=Hn(GS,M∨)H^n_\vee = H^n(G_S, M^\vee), A∗=Hom(A,ℚ/ℤ)A^* = \mathrm{Hom}(A, \mathbb{Q}/\mathbb{Z}), PSn=∏v∈SHn(Kv,M)P^n_S = \prod_{v \in S} H^n(K_v, M), and PS0P^0_S uses Tate cohomology at the infinite places.

The theorem passes to limits. Since the dual of ℤ/ln(−e)\mathbb{Z}/l^n(-e) is ℤ/ln(e+1)\mathbb{Z}/l^n(e+1), it relates the Tate-Shafarevich group of ℚl/ℤl(−e)\mathbb{Q}_l/\mathbb{Z}_l(-e) to H2(GS,ℤl(e+1))H^2(G_S, \mathbb{Z}_l(e+1)). The statement LemmaK of the window bound, for a totally complex field LL, says that this H2H^2 is finite and bounds log⁡#H2\log \# H^2, and ThmBab uses it with PoitouTateDuality.

Selmer and Tate-Shafarevich groups

Definition. Let KK be a number field and let MM be a discrete GKG_K-module. The Tate-Shafarevich group of MM is Ш(K,M)=ker⁡(H1(K,M)→∏vH1(Kv,M)),\text{Ш}(K, M) = \ker\Big(H^1(K, M) \to \prod_v H^1(K_v, M)\Big), over all places vv of KK.

Definition. A Selmer structure ℒ\mathcal{L} on MM is a family of subgroups Lv⊂H1(Kv,M)L_v \subset H^1(K_v, M), one for each place vv, with Lv=Hur1(Kv,M)L_v = H^1_{\mathrm{ur}}(K_v, M) for almost all vv. Its Selmer group is Hℒ1(K,M)={x∈H1(K,M):resv(x)∈Lv for all v}.H^1_{\mathcal{L}}(K, M) = \{x \in H^1(K, M) : \mathrm{res}_v(x) \in L_v \text{ for all } v\}. For finite MM, the dual Selmer structure ℒ∗\mathcal{L}^* on M∨M^\vee takes the annihilators Lv⊥L_v^\perp under local Tate duality.

The same formula with all Lv=0L_v = 0 gives Ш(K,M)\text{Ш}(K, M).

Example. Let AA be an elliptic curve over KK (Chapter 12 defines it), and let LvL_v be the image of the Kummer map A(Kv)/n→H1(Kv,A[n])A(K_v)/n \to H^1(K_v, A[n]). Then there is an exact sequence 0→A(K)/n→Seln(A/K)→Ш(A/K)[n]→00 \to A(K)/n \to \mathrm{Sel}^n(A/K) \to \text{Ш}(A/K)[n] \to 0.

Theorem (Greenberg-Wiles formula; Wiles, 1995). Let MM be a finite GKG_K-module and let ℒ\mathcal{L} be a Selmer structure on MM. Then Hℒ1(K,M)H^1_{\mathcal{L}}(K, M) and Hℒ∗1(K,M∨)H^1_{\mathcal{L}^*}(K, M^\vee) are finite, and #Hℒ1(K,M)#Hℒ∗1(K,M∨)=#H0(K,M)#H0(K,M∨)∏v#Lv#H0(Kv,M).\frac{\#H^1_{\mathcal{L}}(K, M)}{\#H^1_{\mathcal{L}^*}(K, M^\vee)} = \frac{\#H^0(K, M)}{\#H^0(K, M^\vee)} \prod_v \frac{\#L_v}{\#H^0(K_v, M)}.

The factor is 11 when v∤m∞v \nmid m\infty, MM is unramified at vv and LvL_v is unramified, so the product is finite. The proof combines Poitou-Tate duality with both Euler characteristic formulas.

Definition (Bloch-Kato). Let VV be a p-adic representation of GKG_K, unramified outside a finite set, and let T⊂VT \subset V be a GKG_K-stable lattice. For a finite place vv put Hf1(Kv,V)={ker⁡(H1(Kv,V)→H1(Iv,V)),v∤p,ker⁡(H1(Kv,V)→H1(Kv,V⊗ℚpBcris)),v∣p,H^1_f(K_v, V) = \begin{cases} \ker\big(H^1(K_v, V) \to H^1(I_v, V)\big), & v \nmid p, \\ \ker\big(H^1(K_v, V) \to H^1(K_v, V \otimes_{\mathbb{Q}_p} B_{\mathrm{cris}})\big), & v \mid p, \end{cases} and let Hf1(Kv,V/T)H^1_f(K_v, V/T) be its image. The Bloch-Kato Selmer group Hf1(K,V/T)H^1_f(K, V/T) is the Selmer group of V/TV/T for these local conditions; Hf1(K,V)H^1_f(K, V) is defined in the same way.

A class in H1(Kv,V)H^1(K_v, V) is an extension 0→V→X→ℚp→00 \to V \to X \to \mathbb{Q}_p \to 0. If v∣pv \mid p and VV is crystalline at vv (Galois representations), the class lies in Hf1H^1_f exactly when XX is crystalline.

LitCoh has statements named after the Greenberg-Wiles formula and the Bloch-Kato local conditions, and KatoTwoW concludes that the Bloch-Kato Selmer groups of two twists of a two-dimensional representation WW vanish.

Plus and minus parts

Let EE be a CM field with complex conjugation cc, let SS be a set of places of EE stable under cc, and let MM be a discrete ℤl\mathbb{Z}_l-module with an action of Gal(ES/E+)\mathrm{Gal}(E_S/E^+). Conjugation by a lift of cc is an involution of Hn(GS,M)H^n(G_S, M).

Definition. For ll odd and a ℤl\mathbb{Z}_l-module XX with an involution cc, put X±=1±c2XX^{\pm} = \frac{1 \pm c}{2} X. Then X=X+⊕X−X = X^+ \oplus X^-, and the length of XX is the sum of the lengths of X+X^+ and X−X^-.

Example. Complex conjugation acts on μln\mu_{l^n} by ζ↦ζ−1\zeta \mapsto \zeta^{-1}, so it acts on ℤl(k)\mathbb{Z}_l(k) by (−1)k(-1)^k.

The splitting needs 22 to be invertible. So shaLen_eq_add in the window bound splits the length into the part at l=2l = 2 and the (−1)e(-1)^e and (−1)e+1(-1)^{e+1} eigenspaces of cc, which ThmBab, ThmBcFree and ThmHV bound.

Iwasawa theory

Let KK be a number field and let pp be a prime. The cyclotomic ℤp\mathbb{Z}_p-extension is the unique extension K∞/KK_\infty / K in K(μp∞)K(\mu_{p^\infty}) with Γ=Gal(K∞/K)≅ℤp\Gamma = \mathrm{Gal}(K_\infty/K) \cong \mathbb{Z}_p. Its cyclotomic layers are the fields KnK_n with Gal(Kn/K)≅ℤ/pn\mathrm{Gal}(K_n/K) \cong \mathbb{Z}/p^n.

Definition. The Iwasawa algebra is Λ=ℤp[[Γ]]=lim←⁡nℤp[Gal(Kn/K)]\Lambda = \mathbb{Z}_p[[\Gamma]] = \varprojlim_n \mathbb{Z}_p[\mathrm{Gal}(K_n/K)]. A generator γ\gamma of Γ\Gamma gives Λ≅ℤp[[T]]\Lambda \cong \mathbb{Z}_p[[T]] with γ↦1+T\gamma \mapsto 1 + T. Iwasawa theory studies the class groups, Selmer groups and cohomology groups of the layers KnK_n as Λ\Lambda-modules.

Theorem (structure theorem). For a finitely generated torsion Λ\Lambda-module XX there is a map with finite kernel and cokernel X→⨁iΛ/(pmi)⊕⨁jΛ/(fj),X \to \bigoplus_i \Lambda/(p^{m_i}) \oplus \bigoplus_j \Lambda/(f_j), with distinguished polynomials fjf_j. Put μ=∑imi\mu = \sum_i m_i and λ=∑jdeg⁡fj\lambda = \sum_j \deg f_j.

Theorem (Iwasawa, 1959). Let penp^{e_n} be the order of the pp-part of the class group of KnK_n. There are integers μ,λ≥0\mu, \lambda \geq 0 and ν\nu with en=μpn+λn+νe_n = \mu p^n + \lambda n + \nu for all large nn.

Theorem (Ferrero-Washington theorem; Ferrero and Washington, 1979). If KK is an abelian extension of ℚ\mathbb{Q}, then μ=0\mu = 0 for the cyclotomic ℤp\mathbb{Z}_p-extension of KK.

In the window bound, ThmBab uses ferreroWashington to bound the part at l=2l = 2 (BaAt) and the parts over cyclotomic layers (BbAt).

Euler systems and Kato

Let TT be a free ℤp\mathbb{Z}_p-module of finite rank with a continuous GKG_K-action unramified outside a finite set Σ\Sigma of places. Put T∗=Hom(T,ℤp(1))T^* = \mathrm{Hom}(T, \mathbb{Z}_p(1)) and W∗=Hom(T,μp∞)W^* = \mathrm{Hom}(T, \mu_{p^\infty}).

Definition (Rubin, 2000). An Euler system for TT is a family of classes cF∈H1(F,T)c_F \in H^1(F, T), one for each finite abelian extension FF of KK in a fixed family, such that for F⊂F′F \subset F' corF′/F(cF′)=(∏vPv(Frobv−1))cF,\mathrm{cor}_{F'/F}(c_{F'}) = \Big(\prod_{v} P_v(\mathrm{Frob}_v^{-1})\Big) c_F, where vv runs over the places outside Σ∪{p}\Sigma \cup \{p\} that ramify in F′F' but not in FF, and Pv(X)=det⁡(1−Frobv−1X∣T∗)P_v(X) = \det(1 - \mathrm{Frob}_v^{-1} X \mid T^*).

Theorem (Kolyvagin; Rubin, 2000, Theorem 2.2.3). Suppose that cKc_K is not torsion and that the image of GKG_K in Aut(T)\mathrm{Aut}(T) satisfies Rubin's hypotheses. Then a Selmer group of W∗W^*, with the Bloch-Kato conditions away from pp, is finite, with order bounded in terms of the index of cKc_K in H1(K,T)H^1(K, T).

Theorem (Kato Euler system; Kato, 2004). Let ff be a newform of weight k≥2k \geq 2 with p-adic Galois representation VV. Kato builds an Euler system for VV from Beilinson elements in K2K_2 of modular curves, with an explicit reciprocity law that relates it to the values L(f,χ,r)L(f, \chi, r). If 1≤r≤k−11 \leq r \leq k - 1 and L(f,r)≠0L(f, r) \neq 0, the Bloch-Kato Selmer group of the twist of VV that matches L(f,r)L(f, r) is zero (Kato, 2004, Theorem 14.2).

KatoTwoW feeds the count CountI. Its proof katoTwoW_of_printsH has a largest part Kato.Final.zetaUr, whose pieces are named after Kato's Euler system.

Hida theory

Let p≥5p \geq 5 and let N≥1N \geq 1 be prime to pp. A normalized eigenform of level NpNp is ordinary at pp if its UpU_p-eigenvalue is a pp-adic unit. Hida's ordinary projector on p-adic modular forms is e=lim⁡nUpn!e = \lim_n U_p^{n!}.

Theorem (Hida theory; Hida, 1986). Let Λ=ℤp[[1+pℤp]]\Lambda = \mathbb{Z}_p[[1 + p\mathbb{Z}_p]]. The ordinary Hecke algebra 𝕋ord\mathbb{T}^{\mathrm{ord}} of tame level NN is finite and free over Λ\Lambda, and for each k≥2k \geq 2 its specialization at weight kk is the ordinary Hecke algebra of weight kk and level NpNp. So the rank of the ordinary part in weight kk depends only on kk modulo p−1p - 1.

Theorem (Hida, 1986; Wiles, 1988). For each maximal ideal 𝔪\mathfrak{m} of 𝕋ord\mathbb{T}^{\mathrm{ord}} with absolutely irreducible residual representation, a continuous representation Gℚ→GL2(𝕋𝔪ord)G_{\mathbb{Q}} \to \mathrm{GL}_2(\mathbb{T}^{\mathrm{ord}}_{\mathfrak{m}}) interpolates the representations of the ordinary eigenforms. Its restriction to GℚpG_{\mathbb{Q}_p} is upper triangular with an unramified quotient.

In the window bound, core_alt_bis proves DenseThresholdMainCase, on ordinary points of a universal ordinary determinant ring for 2≤n≤42 \leq n \leq 4, and the field hWu of HypsAlt quantifies over each HidaSetting.

Further reading

  • J. Neukirch, A. Schmidt and K. Wingberg, Cohomology of Number Fields, 2nd ed. (2008), chapters I, VII and VIII.
  • J. S. Milne, Arithmetic Duality Theorems, 2nd ed. (2006), chapter I, sections 2 to 5.
  • H. Darmon, F. Diamond and R. Taylor, Fermat's Last Theorem, in Elliptic Curves, Modular Forms and Fermat's Last Theorem (1997), section 2.
  • L. Washington, Introduction to Cyclotomic Fields, 2nd ed. (1997), chapters 7 and 13.
  • K. Rubin, Euler Systems (2000), chapters 1 and 2.

The source of this page. Markdown. Something is wrong? Report it.